Chapter 49 & 50 : Caught in the Act
Matteo hugged Hailey in his sleep that night, savouring her warmth, his heart beating fast showing how much love he had for her.
Next Morning, they woke up to a Knock on the door and then Brandon’s Voice boomed from behind it.
Matteo pay Hailey warmly and softly to wake her up, Hailey stirred in her sleep, shifting closer to Brandon.
“Hailey…your brother is here” Immediately Hailey heard those words, her eyes snaps open with speed.
“He is…Oh My God” Hailey says jumping out of bed pacing the room, tears forming in her eyes.
“Babe..Calm down” Matteo says walking to her, grasping her by the shoulder softly,. looking in her eyes warmly.
“What…what…what if he asks us to break up? what if he doesn’t want to see you ever again? what If he cuts off your friendship? What if…What…what if I never her to see you again?” Hailey voices out her thoughts.
“Wifey… Remember what I said when I revealed my feelings, I said I Will Fought For Us even When Brandon figures Out Okay…Do You Trust me?” Matteo says and asks at the end of his sentence.
Hailey nods not being able to form words because of how choked she feels knowing her brother was here.
They walked out to the parlor holding hands.
“Hailey , I know I’m the last person you want to see right now but please can we talk?” Brandon says from behind the door with a defeated sigh
Hailey slowly walks to the door and opens it revealing Brandon, her eyes widens at the state he looked, His eyes was baggy and had dark circles under it, his lips chapped and dry, his hair scattered but his dressing was a bit decent except for the fact he wore 2 different colored socks.
“Hailey I’m so sorry, I was selfish and didn’t care about how you felt about Matteo, i realizes I had also done the same thing in the past but when you figured out, you were happy for me but there I was behaving like an asshole towards you, I understand if you l..l..love Matteo and I support your relationship okay? Please don’t be mad at me, I can’t stand you being mad at me” Brandon says finding a little bit hard to say Love but finishes his sentence with a low, sad voice.
Hailey looks at Brandon and jumps on him, hugging the life out of him, Brandon didn’t waste time before hugging her back, Anyone who saw the scene would think Hailey and Brandon were dating, well that’s how close they were.
“It’s Alright Brandon, I’m sorry for not telling you and for falling for your best friend when you told me he was off limits” Hailey says but Brandon puts her down, looks her in the eyes and shakes his head.
“We don’t choose who we Love Hailey, I don’t blame you for falling for him, I blame him for seducing you” Brandon says making Hailey laugh as she hit his shoulder.
“Uhmm” They both heard a cough from insider only to see Matteo shirtless and his hand behind his neck, rubbing it nervously.
Brandon walks Hailey inside the house and closes the door, he then turns to Matteo.
“Just so you know, I’m not sorry for hitting you, you deserved him for making a move on my sister and for seducing her heart” Brandon says rolling his eyes but receives a glare from Hailey.
“Okay Fine, maybe I’m a bit sorry but we cool right?” Brandon asks Matteo who smirks.
“Sure” he says and they did their little Bro Hug, Hailey rolled her eyes.
“You Boys are so weird, Only a hug and everything is fixed, for girls you literally have to go spend a whole lot of money before they forgive you” Hailey says crossing her leg in her bum short making it Shorter, revealing her fresh, sexy lap.
Matteo eyes was on that spot, his d*ck growing under his knicker, Brandon looks at Matteo wondering why he was quiet only to see how hard he was staring at Hailey’s Lap , his eyes then went to Matteo’s knicker and his eyes grew wide.
He grabs a couch pillow and hit Matteo in the head before handing it to him, Matteo became embarrassed immediately, Caught in the act hehe
Hailey was confused on what was happening until she saw How Matteo placed the pillow in front of his knicker l, her eyes widens and she Blushes before standing and adjusting her clothes, coughing awkwardly.
“I’m just gonna uhmm excuse myself” Matteo says stuttering a bit before walking to his room in a haste.
Brandon and Hailey’s eyes follow him until he opens the door and slams it shut, Brandon turns to Hailey.
“He Treats You good?” He asks making his way to the door about to leave.
“No…He Treats me Right” Hailey says with a proud face, Brandon smiles at her and took his hand to her hair, ruffling it.
“Be careful” He says and then walks out, Hailey smiles and closes the door behind her resting her forehead on it.
“Well That was Peaceful than I thought it would be” Hailey hears and turns to see Shawn with a smirk on his face, seeing that smirk, she was immediately reminded of Ginnie.
They would make a great couple She thought and pick up a couch pillow throwing it at Shawn.
“Oh Shut Up” She says watch him dodge it and laugh as he enters his room, Hailey knew Shawn was right, it was peaceful.
~2 WEEKS LATER>>
Hailey and Freya had spend these 2 weeks exploring the City to the extent it bored them.
They decided to go back home and spend the last week there, Hailey and Freya had packed their bags ready while Matteo and Brandon only packed what they needed.
Soon they were on a night flight home, They got home really late that night and all decided to spend the night at Mendel Mansion instead of going back to their various homes.
They got there and the gate was owned to them by the Security Guard who immediately recognizes them.
They walked to the main door and inputted the pin to the door which got it opening.
They entered only too meet darkness which meant Their Parents had gone on another Business Trip.
“Hmm feels like home” Hailey says turning on the light and stretching to relieve the stress in her bones.
“Hey Freya..wanna…” Hailey was about to as Freya if she wanted to sleep.in her room only to turn and see Brandon already dragging Freya up the stairs.
“Well she’s gone” Hailey says placing her hand on her waist, Matteo smiles seeing her expression before walking closer to her and whispering to her ear.
“I’m here” He says and Hailey rolled her eyes at him.
“Wow really?? I totally forgot” She says sarcastically before dragging her luggage up the stairs and to her room, Matteo followed her like a lost puppy.
They Got there and entered closing the door behind them, Hailey places her luggage by the side and was about walking to the bathroom to wash her face but was suddenly pinned to the wall.
“What?” she asks Matteo.
“I’m kiss starved” Matteo says and Hailey raises her brow.
“There’s no such thing….” She swallowed her words when Matteo pulled her into a hot kiss in which she had no choice but to reciprocate.
Chapter 51 & 52 : The Final Decision
“How do I Look?” Hailey asks Matteo as she twirls in front of him she was wearing a yellow sundress and her black flat shoe which was her 6th outfit.
“We’re just going to visit my Parents Wifey, It’s not a big deal” Matteo says rolling his eyes, Hailey pouts looking at him.
“It’s a big deal for me, I’m meeting my Future Husband Parents for the first time” Hailey mutters lowly, Matteo heard a blushes,. looking away
“I’ll go with this” Hailey says looking at herself in the mirror.
“Finally” Matteo says standing up and walking to her, he drew her closer by the waist making Hailey gasps at the sudden movement.
“Shall we?” Matteo asks bringing his face closer to Hailey’s who nods smiling at him.
They held hands and began walking out if her room and down the stairs, they got there to meet Freya on Brandon’s lap feeding him Pancake
“PDA Much” Hailey says and they both turned to her, Brandon rolled his eyes.
“Good Luck” Freya says to Hailey who sends her a flying kiss, Brandon pretended to catch it and places it on his chest making Hailey laugh, Matteo rolled his eyes jealously.
“Don’t be Jelly Hubby” Hailey says.
“Wait…What?” Brandon asks hearing What Hailey called Matteo but they slammed the door in his face.
They got to Matteo’s car and entered, the security guard opened the gate for them to pass through.
Hailey and Matteo got there, Hailey kept rubbing her hand together nervously in which Matteo noticed, He holds her hand.
“It’s Okay…Chill” Matteo says comfortingly and Hailey nods and they began walking to the gate.
The Security Guard looks at the Computer connected to the CCTV camera by the gate and when he spots Matteo, he unlocks the gate without hesitation.
They entered and began walking to the door, Matteo pressed the door bell and in a minute, the door was opened by Mano, Matteo’s 6 Year old Younger sister.
“Matt!!!!” She shouts jumping on him giggling, Matteo catches her and hugs her kissing her allover her face making her laugh cutely.
“Mano who’s that?” Mrs James says and walks to the door and when she sees Matteo, her eyes widens, she pulls him until a tight hug.
“I missed you too Mom” Matteo says before disengaging from the hug, They all entered before Mrs James Noticed Hailey who felt invincible
“Who’s this Angel?” Mrs James throwing a teasing glance at Matteo.
“Mom, Mano…Meet My Girlfriend Hailey Mendel” Matteo Introduces.
“Wait..Hailey as in Hailey Mendel.. Brandon’s Younger sister, The Girl you never stop talking about when you were younger” Mrs James says and when Hailey hears the last sentence, she turns to Matteo who blushes embarrassingly and looks away.
“It’s been so long since I’ve seen you..Wow you’ve really grown really beautiful” Mrs James says loving Hailey already who smiles.
“Where’s Dad?” Matteo asks, Mrs James already knew they reconcilated.
“At Work” Mrs James says the obvious.
“I Just Finished Cooking Breakfast, Please join us” Mrs James says to Hailey who nods and follows Mrs James to the dining.
“Mom… She’s my Girlfriend not yours” Matteo says jealously.
“Don’t be jelly Sweetheart” Mrs James says and Hailey turns to Matteo sticking her tongue out to him, Matteo smirks and lick her tongue with his making Hailey blush.
“Mom!!! Matt is licking Hwaiwey tongue” Mano shouts not able to saw Hailey’s name well, Hailey and Matteo’s eyes widen, A slipper from nowhere hit Matteo on the head, His eyes rolled to the back and BOOM he went flat on the ground.
~4 HOURS LATER>>
“Thanks for The Breakfast Mrs James” Hailey says thanking her, Matteo had woken up 30 minutes after he fainted.
“Ooh Darling…Call me Mum” Mrs James says hugging Hailey.
“Okay Mr..I Mean Mum” Hailey changes her words when she noticed she was about to say Mrs James.
“Don’t Worry, you’ll get used to it” Mrs James Chuckled and walked back into the house.
“Bye Matt and Haiwey” Mano says waving getting Hailey’s name wrong agai, Matteo and Hailey waved at her Before they saw her close the door with her little hands.
“That wasn’t that bad ,was it?” Matteo says immediately they got in his car, Hailey smiles and nods finally relaxing.
“Your mom’s Nice” Hailey says and Matteo nods.
“Yeah and I Love Her” Matteo says and turns the ignition on before driving out the gate,.He drove for a while and Hailey noticed he was heading the opposite way home.
“Where are we going?” Hailey asks and Matteo smiles.
“To Meet My brother” Matteo says and Hailey immediately knew they were going to the cemetery.
~30 MIN LATER>>
Matteo opens the door for Hailey in which she comes out from, she breathe in the fresh air before looking in front to see the gate of the City Cemetery.
They Both walked in after confirming from the Security Man that was always there.
They Walked deep inside till they got to a spot where there was no burial ground except the in front of them.
“Hey Brother” Matteo says kneeling in front, He looks at Hailey who was just looking at him before she joined him kneeling.
“I hope You’re living in peace up there, Bianca too…I want to introduce you to someone really important to me, My lifeline, The one my heart beats for, You already know her but just that she’s all grown up, It’s Hailey..Yeah The Hailey you always ship me with, Brandon’s Little sister” Matteo says remembering when Matthew would tell him that he would date Hailey in the future , giving them couples name, Haven’t chuckles.
“Hi Matthew…I’m Hailey…I can’t really remember how you look because I was really young then but I just want to assure you that I’ll take care of this knucklehead for you, he’s really stubborn and get jealous very easily but He’s doing fine and I Love Him A Lot” Hailey says while Matteo watched her throughout.
Immediately A Huge wind blew and a tree leaf fell on Matteo’s Hand, he looks at it and looks at Matthew grave.
Thanks for showing me a sign that you’re doing good up there…I Love You Matthew Matteo says holding the leaf tightly before putting it in his pocket.
“Let’s Go” Matteo says and they both stood up and walked out of the cemetery.
They didn’t go hooke straight but drove found the city buying Street food and having fun, Matteo bought them a Couple necklace, Hailey with the Key and he with the heart.
“You’re the key to my heart” he says when Hailey asks why she got the key.
It was going to be Sunset soon so they decided to go to a beach and watch the sunset, They sat on the sand of the beach waiting for the sunset
“Hey I have a question” Hailey says looking up at him since she was resting on his leg, her head in his leg though.
“Shoot” Matteo says urging her to ask her question.
“When Brandon found out We were together and you got Hurt or mad or whatever and I slept in the living room,… You took me to your room and I was sure I heard you say something like Forever and Waterfalls” Hailey says and Matteo shook his head laughing.
“No Wifey” Matteo says laughing.
“What was it then?” Hailey asks and Matteo interlocked their hand kissing it.
“Forever and Always” Matteo says and Hailey eyes twinkled.
“Forever and Always?” She asks to be sure she heard correctly.
“With You…Forever and Always with you” Matteo says.
That Day They Both watched the Sunset together and wished to watch more together.
THE END
Last Words
Hearts were broken, secrets were spilled, and, honestly, it was one big emotional rollercoaster. But here’s the thing—sometimes, the messiest love stories are the ones that teach us the most about who we are and what we truly want. Hailey learned that love isn’t always about happy endings; sometimes, it’s about the journey, the mistakes, and the growth that comes from it all.
And as for Matteo? Well, let’s just say he’ll always have a special place in Hailey’s heart, but she knows now that some loves are meant to be let go, even if it hurts. Life moves on, but those memories? They’ll stay with her—forever and always.
Read More:
Crushing On The Bad Boy – Heartbreak Love Story
Falling For My Stepbrother – Step Brother Sex Story
Caught In Love – College Love Story